|
Private Equity Panel Point to Increases in Scrutiny, Pricing for
Middle Market Deals |
Private
equity veterans are collectively holding their breath to see
what the future holds for the health of the middle market deals
in light of the current credit crunch.
At this year's "Private Equity Outlook," hosted by the Graziadio
School of Business and Management and the Los Angeles Venture
Association and organized by the Graziadio Alumni Network
Council of Los Angeles and its chair, Lori Williams, a group of
industry experts lent their own voices to the ensuing of
discussion of the impact of America's credit crisis. |
|
 |
|
Most pointed to signs of weakness
in middle market investments and consumer spending.
"It's a very fluid market, certainly in the debt market. We expect it to
remain slow for acquiring businesses in the second quarter," said
Michael Carr, VP of Buyouts for American Capital Strategies. "We hope
that by the end of the second quarter we will see a turnaround in middle
market M&As."
Deal pricing has increased while leverage multiples have dropped said
Beth Page, Managing Director of Riverside Company. "Debt capacity for
middle market deals is still there but it's become more expensive. I
think deals will still get done, but I do wonder if sellers will look at
the market uncertainty and pull back."
"People started talking about the next distress cycle three years ago,"
noted Peter Spasov, Director, Marlin Equity Partners. "Consumers are
tightening their wallets and we're starting to see bankruptcies on the
retail side and an uptick in distressed properties."
Tom Turpin, Managing Director of Allied Capital, said that it has become
more challenging for companies with $15M or more in EBITDA to find
loans. "No lender wants to hold all of the debt." He sees a return to
early 2000 models when creditors were more interested in holding loans
than in selling them. Still, he believes the industry is in better shape
that most are admitting.
"Corporate defaults were at a 30-year low –
one-third of one percent -- last year," he said. "Usually leveraged loan
defaults run between eight to ten percent during a recession. The
question is really what's going to happen over the next year, and that's
largely going to be a result of the impact of the stimulus."
Panelists also reported an increase in lender scrutiny, particularly for
deals tied to homes, energy and other trouble spots in the US economy.
"Lenders are really focusing on the quality of the business now," says
Larry Simon, principal for Clearview Capital LLC. "We went out to market
on a deal that was loosely tied to homes and we had a handful of lenders
turn us down. We want to see numbers monthly and weekly to really
understand how a business like that is performing." Most panelists
expect similar rates of return -- 3-3.5 x cash on cash return and
upwards of 20 percent IRR – but noted that returns have dipped as the
private equity industry has matured.
"There's no question that rates of return are coming down," said Michel
Glouchevitch, General Partner, Riordan, Lewis & Haden. "Ultimately the
institutional funds will be looking at alternatives. When you compare
our returns, what we call the alternative asset class, against the
public funds return, there's still a wide gap that more than compensates
for the lack of liquidity but that gap has been narrowing. It may make
it tougher to raise funds in the future for private equity which may
ultimately, in the long run, stabilize the returns at some acceptable
premium to what you would get at some public funds which are more
liquid. Somehow it all works out." To read
more go to
http://lwandassoc.com/articles.htm
___________________________________________________________________
Recession who knows? It may be time to read the numbers.
Daily on CNBC another well-known economic pundit hints at
the possibility of a recession. This week’s “recession-sentiment
warriors” included the great Warren Buffet and the consummate innovator
Sir Richard Brandon, Chairman of the Virgin Group. Moreover, most
economic pundits now believe that we will experience an economic slow
down with some sectors being hit harder than others. While there are
still a few lingering questions, enough compelling data exists to
suggest that companies should engage in some strategic counter-recession
planning.
Officially, a recession is defined as “a significant decline in economic
activity spread across the economy, lasting more than a few months,
normally visible in real GDP, real income, employment, industrial
production, and wholesale-retail sales” (National Bureau of Economic
Research). A recession is only officially recognized when the (NBER)
declares it to be so. Whether or not we are actually in a recession is
really a mute point when making real-time business decisions. Business
owners shouldn't wait for historical data to take the critical steps
that will be needed to weather the economic storm. So, the real question
becomes what to do in an economic slowdown—if you are an institutional
or individual investor or a CEO of a large or a privately held company.
The applicable answer: Define the fundamental economic position by
analyzing your industry, company, customer base, cost structure, debt
leverage and retained earnings.
All industries are not created or destroyed equally, and some companies
are better positioned for economic uncertainty. To analyze each
industry, evaluate the economic impact on its customers and suppliers if
a slowdown were to occur. If the conclusion is troubling—accept the
inevitable and perform an analysis to determine the ability of your
company to adjust to the evident economic impact. This involves a review
of the cost structure, debt leverage and retained earnings.
The cost structure identifies the profit margin and your company’s
ability to absorb overhead cost. Higher margins allow greater cost
flexibility. Additionally, a reduction in overhead may be easier than
cutting production cost, especially if inflation is competing factor.
The balance sheet will reveal your debt leverage and the strength of
your borrowing power. Retained earnings examine the past performance of
your business model and your management team. If the retained earnings
tell a story of past negative growth, the business model's ability to
take an additional hit will be questionable at best.
In the case of a company with less favorable financial position,
innovation may be the only solution. Since negative growth and declining
retained earnings impact the balance sheet and reduces a company’s
ability to obtain debt or equity investment, your company may need to
form a strategic alliance or joint venture to allow reorganization
without a substantial reinvestment of funds.
We may be heading for tough economic times and, no doubt, some companies
will not survive the squall. However, there are many examples of
companies that have escaped disaster through leadership and vision. It's
no secret that markets trade on sentiment and the “mood” can lift or
pummel the economy. In times of economic uncertainty, your preparation
and strength of will are genuine assets.
To read more go articles written by Lori Williams go to
http://lwandassoc.com/articles.htm or
http://blog.lwandassociates.com/
|